Discrimination Complaint Filed Against Wissahickon School District
District releases a statement, calls the complaint 'curious.'
The complaint was filed to the United States Department of Education (DOE). It alleges that the Wissahickon School District was discriminating against those in the Hispanic community by not translating messaging about the closure of Mattison Avenue Elementary School into alternative languages.
According to a released statement from the district, the Wissahickon board finds the claims "curious."
"This Complaint was filed over six weeks after the completion of the public hearing related to the school closure issue," said the district statement. "The Complaint curiously makes no mention of the fact that the District provided translation services during the hearing process, nor that the District translated into Spanish various notice and content-based documents during the school closure hearing process."
The district asked the community to be patient as it investigates the matter. Private counsel has been assigned to cover the district in the matter.
"Members of the Wissahickon community should recognize that the fact that mere allegations have been made in a complaint does not mean that those allegations have any merit whatsoever," said the statement.
The time and money the district is forced to use was noted as a point of apparent frustration.
"The District will necessarily be required to expend substantial funds and, more importantly, the valuable time of its Board members and administrators in properly defending these allegations," said the released statement.
The district's statement noted its innocence in the matter, as well.
"In sum, the allegations are without merit and the District will at all times continue to treat persons of all national origins and races fairly and equally and
as required by law," it said.
The complaint was initially covered by a Jan. 11 blog by Karen Palmer on Ambler Patch.
The initial letter, the concerned parents said that the district was at fault for discriminating in two ways.
The letter noted they "discriminates against Hispanic students on the basis of race by proposing the closure of the Mattison Avenue Elementary School (the School), which will have a disparate impact on Hispanic students" and secondly, "discriminates against Hispanic parents on the basis of national origin by failing to provide effective methods of communication to Hispanic parents at the School who are limited in English proficiency."
Attached within this story is the letter received in response to the complaint as filed with the U.S. Department of Education. It is dated Dec. 18, 2012. The Office for Civil Rights (OCR) said it will look into the matter.
"We will investigate these allegations because the OCR has jurisdiction and the allegations were filed timely," reads the DOE letter, written and signed by Rhasheda S. Douglas, team leader. The letter is on DOE letterhead. "Please note that investigating and allegation in no way implies that OCR has decided its merits."
According to an article in the Ambler Gazette last week, the complaint states communications were not translated throughout the closure discussions.
"The school community takes it upon themselves to translate, so anything from the school is in Spanish but no communication via email, U.S. mail, schoolbag or phone is translated," said the complaint. "These people have no voice."
The name of the person who filed the complaint has not been released by the DOE because it "could reasonably be expected to constitute an unwarranted invasion of privacy," said the Gazette report.
One parent at a recent meeting noted this lack of fairness.
"The Hispanic community in Ambler had no knowledge about the possible closure of Mattison, until a bilingual parent met with them on the playground after school in September," said Mattison Avenue mother Christine Delaurentis, according to the Gazette.
She said, in a recent school board meeting on the matter, that it was unfair that some parents were unaware.
"Those poor parents sat there for that entire two-hour hearing and had no idea what was going on, because they were not allowed to know," said Delaurentis. "Don’t lie to the people of this district."
In addition to the language barriers, the complaint to the DOE alleges the new "alternative school" offered in response to the Mattison Avenue closure is unreasonable for the Hispanic community.
A report on StudyInStates.com said the issues surrounding transportation were a large concern.
"The complaint also states the closure of Mattison Avenue negatively impacts the Latino community because most in the community do not own vehicles," said the StudyInStates website. "While Mattison Avenue is a walkable school, the alternative school is allegedly 'inaccessible via public transportation and walking is prohibitive' because there are no sidewalks and the roads leading to the school are dangerous."
The lack of preschool programs, the site said, was another concern noted in the complaint.
"It further states the closure of Mattison Avenue will allegedly lead to the end the Head Start program in Ambler, leaving a lasting negative impact on the community that relies on the program to help Spanish-speaking children learn English at a young age," said the article.
Malika Batwinda Hightower III
7:13 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
So is curious the word of the day? Whether this is or is not a claim with valid merit, I can say (as a black person who went thru Wissahickon school district) that the above complaint pales in comparison to the discrimination that I received, as well as viewed going through the school system. I wish I had the knowledge as well as support needed to stand up for myself as well as make them accountable for some of the teachers that were and most likely still are employed. I firmly believe in karma so I hold no grudges. But If I had a child they most definitely NEVER attend school within this district!
Kenny Poe
7:58 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
Wow, what a bunch of victacrats. WSD is one of the most inclusive districts in the region, bending over backwards to make "multi-culturalism" a prominent part of the curriculum, even to the point of slighting the significance of European settlement. My (immigrant) grandparents came to this country and COULDN'T WAIT to learn the language and become American. Multi-culturalism has changed all of that.
Walt Priestley
8:15 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
English is the official language of the United States of America. Learn it!
Malika Batwinda Hightower III
8:19 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
Please tell me you're being sarcastic and/or ironic. People really think like this? How small minded. Please put your dunce cap on and go in the corner. People who think like this are a the poster child or prime example of why we as human beings aren't where we could be. I feel sorry for you if you honestly feel like this. Let me finish with this question. Could you see yourself learning another language such as spanish to better be able to communicate with immigrants?
Anita Pieri
8:52 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Sadly Walt, we have never declared English the official language. Politicians, with no guts, never addressed it. Never forget, politicians are worried more about the job they have, than doing the right thing for our nation.
Anita Pieri
9:41 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
Well said! Both of you.
Donna Picotta
8:42 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
Never heard of such a thing. Apparently these parents/guardians do not listen to their children. I am sure they have the ability to converse and understand English, and communicate with others. How can they attend a school, learn English, then not apply what they have learned to everyday tasks? Not everything at a Walmart or McDonalds is in two languages. I don't see them being sued for not telling you what comes on a hamburger, or for what is not in aisle 3. This has nothing to do with race, it has to do with ignorance. When immigrants enter an area they must take the initiative to learn the culture and language of others. There are some of us who want others to learn about our cultures, but really we should be learning about theirs too!
Malika Batwinda Hightower III
9:30 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
Donna, do you realize that the Unites States of America is in the minority regarding this language issue? English is widely spoke and known, but in most countries people know more than just one language. So yes-they should make an effort to learn the English language. But don't you think the bigger issue is that we, as Americans make NO effort to learn anything outside of ourselves'. We're the ones' that are losing. American culture isn't the end all and be all.
Kimberly
10:13 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
Many of these parents ARE learning English, but as we all know, it is a skill much easier learned as a child. These parents are interested in their children's education and want to be active members of the school community. The fact that they are not yet fluent in English (with all of its subtleties and idiosyncrasies) should not mean that they be dismissed. The kids are better at English and do translate for their parents, but I am sure that the staff at the school were not giving children in grades K-3 information about the process for them to pass along. This entire process has been complicated enough without adding the handicap of not being able to understand much of what is being said.
Christine DeLaurentis
8:59 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
The entirety of my comments from the Ambler Gazette is shown below. The above excerpts don't make sense by themselves.
"Mattison Avenue parent Christine Delaurentis said during the meeting in reply to the district’s official statement that Wolpert was “not forthcoming with the information” he was providing.
“The Hispanic community in Ambler had no knowledge about the possible closure of Mattison, until a bilingual parent met with them on the playground after school in September,” she said.
She said the community repeatedly made requests for documents to be translated into Spanish before the district agreed to translate them. She said the only reason a translator was at the first hearing in October was because of repeated requests.
“And in fact, the translator was told to only translate for parents who wanted to speak to the board,” she said. “They were not allowed to translate the rest of the hearing for those parents.”
She said bilingual parents who offered to translate were told they were not allowed to translate because the district translator was already there.
“Those poor parents sat there for that entire two-hour hearing and had no idea what was going on, because they were not allowed to know” she said. “Don’t lie to the people of this district.”
Thank you for bringing this important issue to the public.
Karen Palmer
9:34 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
Both the article and the school districts' response fail to mention that the district received Title I and Title III federal funding for translation and interpretation services that was spent without providing the services. At the WSD, the burden of non-English communication falls on the Home & School Association at the individual school level and paid for by the supporters of the association. The district has to explain what happened with the spent funds.
Amy Joyce
10:25 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
I am baffled as to how WSD can be described as an "inclusive" district that "bends over backwards" to embrace multi-culturalism when they neither recognize or celebrate black history month. Their actions speak for themselves, quite loudly, if one has the ability to listen objectively, of course.
Kenny Poe
4:59 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013
Wrong. They celebrate it...ad nauseum. To the point that the children don't feel special and empowered...they feel singled out, separate, and different...exactly the opposite intent of the "feel good" agenda of the multi-culturalists.
Donna Picotta
11:09 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
Who was there to translate for the parents during the first marking period conferences, as well as back to school night? Maybe they should have realized the problem earlier in the year. As far as Black History Month, Wissahickon is one of the few that gives students off an extra day for MLK day.
Amy Joyce
11:54 am on Monday, February 4, 2013
Donna, exactly the point. They have failed miserably, for quite some time. It's unfortunate we didn't realize just how bad things were until we started really paying attention. And giving our students a day off is in no way a substitute for educating them.
Karen Palmer
12:15 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013
When the district accepted the funding many years ago, solutions should have been put into place district wide.
This is part of the whole opening of Pandora's box that has occurred and is still happening with the current administration and board.
No one really pays complete attention to how things are running until a discovery of 'something not being right'.
There is a long road ahead for the current appointed and elected leaders in the district as a lot of folks are now paying microscopic attention to school district matters which translates to improvements district-wide in the long run.
Donna Picotta
2:18 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013
Amy: How many conducted community service in the African American communities (ex: throughout our area and Philadelphia)? Why didn't you get any press coverage? You are limiting yourself. Move ahead of the crowd!!
T Graefe
3:00 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013
Not one parent or guardian at Mattison Avenue Elem. ever received communication that our school was possibly closing after the announcement was made at a board meeting in June 2012. A letter home to each household announcing the closure and the next steps should have immediately followed this announcement. This was a major announcement that has a huge impact on the lives of our children and their education and it definitely warranted a letter directly from the administration.
penllynjohn
10:08 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013
As a WSD taxpayer,I believe the WSD Board is Federally guilty as charged of intentional ,or unintentional racism, by closing Mattison Avenue School. By depriving the poverty Black and Latino population of Ambler, with no cars, who have no ability to get to Shady Grove Elementary School, of routine interaction with all levels of WSD staff, the effect is intensely, even if through not thinking of it, racist and the Federal Suit,to my taxpayer's dismay, is correct.
Mattison Elementary School must be restored and made properly functional for its' present and coming population and all the racially insensitive Board members who voted to close Mattison, and the Administrators behind them, need to go.
The closure is effective "Redlining", driving minorities out of Ambler to get into more humane School Districts . As such, it is against existing State and Federal Law.
Cave in on this School Board or you will be bankrupted by lawsuits and ,thus, prevented from even renovating your Middle-High School, let alone building new Upper Dublin clones.
brian
11:15 am on Tuesday, February 5, 2013
You're only as good as you peer group. Moving "poverty black and latino population of ambler" into move diverse and more affluent areas benefits the ambler folk. why wouldnt you want to move into all blue-ribbon schools?
BTW: if you're within 1/2 mile of a school, you walk. otherwise it's PA law that you have transportation provided free for you (ie. SCHOOL BUSES)
Kenny Poe
12:31 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013
Do you hear yourself? "Unintentional racism"?? You want to sue at the federal level for "unintentional racism." How is it racism if it's UNINTENTIONAL?? It can't be, by definition. Way to cheapen the term. And btw, there's no mention of the white children that go to Mattison and live in the area. I know they don't fit your victim narrative, but ignoring them is, in fact...racism!
brian
11:11 am on Tuesday, February 5, 2013
Learn English.
My wife is a public school teacher in montco and our native citizens can barely speak and write English. And we're supposed to focus on an alternative language? In a perfect world we would all speak every language spoken in the world, but human beings are currently incapable or unwilling to do so. To say that we are "close-minded" because we want citizens of the USA to speak English is absurd. We need our citizens, regardless where they're from, to speak English and read/write in English. LEARN IT immigrants and natural citizens!
penllynjohn
2:12 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013
To Brian:
It is 3 miles,via Google search, for where most of the Ambler Latino parents live, to walk on busy dangerous roads with no sidewalks, to pick up a Shady Grove grade school child who gets sick at school or when a parent-staff conference is called for .This unintentionally will discourage parental involvement and encourage them to locate elsewhere. Remember, the Latinos have no cars and do not know how to drive.
Mattison was also the site where Head Start gave Latino pre-schoolers a modicum of English,so they can begin to translate for their parents. That will be abolished also, thanks to our School Board's vote, blocking this important first step in English language assimilation.
penllynjohn
2:33 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013
To Ken Po:
I believe racism and redlining can be unintentional.
I was giving the School Board the benefit of the doubt in regard to the harm their vote caused to minority Latino and Black family structures barely hanging on,in Ambler.
I hope the Board truly intended noble purposes and were just ignorant of what real poverty and immigrant experiences are like for these fragile "least of these", the ones who mow lawns and are aides in nursing homes,etc.
I suspect most of the Caucasians attending Mattison Avenue have access to a car. The upper-class Board forgetting that fact is where the insenitivity and unawareness exists in regard to the poverty population in Ambler,showing their ignoring, ignorance and/or neglect in working around fundamental poverty realities.
Kenny Poe
3:26 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013
"Remember, the Latinos have no cars and do not know how to drive." "I suspect most of the Caucasians attending Mattison Avenue have access to a car." Wow, John. Not only are these statements absurd, but reveal a racist view of the world you want to accuse others of having. So in your world, whites, not matter how poor, are never impoverished. And Latinos, no matter what, never has as much as poor whites. That's what you're saying.
Donna Picotta
3:17 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013
Are we discussing race, or are we discussing rights. Everyone is entitled to a good public education. We elect the school board, and we have a vote as far as who will become governor. If you are not satisfied with the qualities of public education, there are more choices than ever, private, cyber, charter. It is like "Farming", if you are going to talk bad about it, don't do it with your mouth full"! You too can run for a school board position, but you didn't. Next time vote for someone who will make a change in your favor. There are even citizens who will pick you up at your house if you do not have a car!
Liz Kunzier
5:41 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013
Last time I checked the only people who drove needy parents to and from Shady Grove for conferences and school meetings were myself and another volunteer parent. The volunteer list comes out at every conference interval. I drove white people, grandmothers of both colors, Spanish speaking people and black people.
Mark Methlie
5:52 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013
These comments prove that racism is not restricted to Western Europeans.
Anita Pieri
6:13 pm on Friday, February 8, 2013
I suppose that we have entered the world of entitlements that will transcend every aspect of life as we know it. Translation for every language for every immigrant that comes to our shores, legally or otherwise. While you are at, provide transportation for their every need, even though they came here to embrace the American dream...or did they? Just for the record, Mattison only goes to the third grade, so following that, how would any of these parents go to parent conferences? Maybe we should build a middle school and high school in the neighborhood to accommodate those that don't have cars!
Ms. Foster
3:14 pm on Tuesday, February 12, 2013
Very well said Anita!!!!!
Liz Kunzier
9:11 am on Monday, February 11, 2013
Again, little kids; not ideology or republican or democrat; or "entitled", little tiny kids who need help. Mattison's principal isn't the person who translated - it was a bi-lingual parent. It happened at back to school night in September on the playground. The families only knew what their neighbors told them, because the announcement was never sent home or publicized and it was made at a school board meeting after the last day of school was over. The only people who even knew it was to be announced were the people who regularly check the school board agenda which was posted at 2 PM on the last day of school which ended at 10:30 AM. If you did not attend the meeting - anything you heard was by word of mouth.Yes, it was the community who told the families; not anyone from the school district. This is the fear: when you take the community school away, who will help? We know some of the families whose children attend Mattison need help; and we as a community help them. The school will now close, the need is still there, the community ties will be severed.To this point - before the press started making everyone aware; the only people who helped were community members; and that was sufficient. What happens when you sever that tie? Will you all who have such strong opinions volunteer to help? Will you follow these kids to two different schools, or three different schools? I know I will.
Ms. Foster
3:10 pm on Tuesday, February 12, 2013
Really....with all the information that comes home from Mattison in spanish!!!! Lawsuit is frivilous and non-meritorious!
Christine DeLaurentis
11:41 pm on Tuesday, February 12, 2013
The district has nothing to do with the translated information that is sent home from Mattison Avenue. Volunteer, bilingual parents translate everything themselves. Information that originates from the school is sent home in both English and Spanish (on either side of the same piece of paper).
In the past, there have been multiple requests to the district for them to also supply a Spanish translation of district information, and those request have been ignored.
Likewise, when the students of Mattison Avenue move on to Shady Grove they no longer receive information translated into Spanish.
The district administration only translated the Mattison School closure documents after repeated requests of parents. District documents have only recently started being sent home with a translation.The administration's efforts to display their "concern" for the Hispanic community have only started after they received notice of the federal investigation.
Christine DeLaurentis
11:43 pm on Tuesday, February 12, 2013
..oh, and it isn't a lawsuit. It is a federal investigation. No one is suing anyone in regards to the above, that I'm aware of anyway.
penllynjohn
1:12 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013
Yesterday I learned of what I believe is the first Latino family with little kids planning to leave Ambler,since the redlining force-out caused by the Board's closure of Mattison Avenue.They will break up their extended family support in Ambler and relocate to Flourtown and its' schools because that grade school will be within walking distance for the non-driving mother and where the mother works. Government school boards forcing poverty minorities to relocate like this is racially discriminatory .Is WSD in Alabama in the 50's?
JEVsharp
10:54 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013
Penllynjohn - What was the "non-driving mom" who works in Flourtown planning to do when her children reached grades 4/5 at Shady Grove? Guess what...Ambler is NOT the only town within the WSD where non-English speaking, non-driving parents live. Do you think that the district's "poverty minorities" that you write about live ONLY in Ambler? There are students living in Lower Gywnedd and Blue Bell with non-English speaking parents and they are doing just fine.
Donna Picotta
7:57 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013
Let us know where the house is located. People are really interested in Whitpain/Ambler area because of the schools and demographics.
Crime level must not be high enough up here. They will now be closer to Philly, leaving the amateurs and seeking the professionals
Donna Picotta
7:57 pm on Wednesday, February 13, 2013
Adios. Via con dios!!